Many good manuscripts are rejected within days of submission, before any reviewer sees them. Editors call this a desk rejection, and one of the most common reasons is simple: the paper does not fit the journal. Choosing well before you submit saves months.
Start with your audience, not the impact factor
Ask who most needs to read your findings. Clinicians? Policy-makers? Methodologists in your own subfield? The right journal is the one those readers already follow. A well-placed paper in a focused journal often gets more relevant citations than a poorly fitting paper in a famous one.
The checklist
1. Aims and scope
Read the journal's aims and scope page in full, then skim the last two or three issues. Have they published papers using similar methods, on similar populations or questions? If you cannot find any close neighbours to your paper, think again.
2. Article types and length
Check that the journal accepts your article type (original research, review, short communication, case report) and that your word count, figure count and reference count are within its limits.
3. Peer review model
Is review single-blind, double-blind or open? How many reviewers are typical? Credible journals describe their process clearly and name their editorial board, with members you can verify.
4. Indexing
Check where the journal is indexed, for example Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed or DOAJ for open-access titles. Verify these claims on the indexing service's own website, not just the journal's.
5. Open access and fees
If the journal charges an article processing charge (APC), it should be stated openly before submission. Check whether your institution or funder has an agreement that covers fees, and whether your funder requires open access, as many UK funders now do.
6. Timelines
Look for published figures on time to first decision and time to publication. Many journals print "received", "accepted" and "published" dates on each article, which give you a realistic picture.
7. Licensing and copyright
Open-access articles are usually published under a Creative Commons licence such as CC BY 4.0. Make sure you understand who keeps copyright and what you may do with your own work afterwards.
Write a cover letter that helps the editor
Keep it short. State what you found, why it matters, and why it suits this journal's readers. Confirm that the work is original, not under consideration elsewhere, and that all authors approve the submission. Mention any data or code availability.
Prepare for revision
Most accepted papers go through at least one round of revision. Respond to every reviewer comment point by point, explain what you changed and where, and stay courteous even where you disagree. A clear response letter often decides whether a revision is accepted.
Where KSR Press fits
The four KEYSTONE Research Press journals, covering social inquiry, biomedical and clinical research, finance and business strategy, and computational and intelligent engineering, are being built on these principles: clear scope, transparent peer review, open access and published editorial standards. See the journals in development and subscribe to hear when each opens for submissions.
References
- Think. Check. Submit. — Checklist for researchers (thinkchecksubmit.org).
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Core practices.
- Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). Guide to applying and transparency principles.


